Online Store Case Study

Sold Out: 575 Tickets and a 6x Return on Ad Spend

How we helped a South Florida church sell out its flagship women’s conference

6.02x

return on ad spend

105%

of the paid ticket goal

575

tickets into a 578-seat room

9.96x

return from the smallest campaign

Women lining up outside the She's COOL Experience 2026 conference, with the case study title and COOL Church and Sociallybuzz logos

At a Glance

  • Client: COOL Church, Miami Gardens and Miramar, Florida
  • Industry: Faith, nonprofit, events
  • Services: Paid social, conversion tracking, Meta advertising, campaign strategy
  • Timeline: 5 weeks
  • Platforms: Meta (Facebook, Instagram), Eventbrite

The Challenge:

COOL Church is a multi-campus church in South Florida, with campuses in Miami Gardens and Miramar and an online campus. She’s COOL Experience is its annual women’s conference, and the 2026 goal was 500 tickets.

The church had been promoting itself on social media for years. What it didn’t have was a clear way to see which ads were actually turning into ticket sales.

With five weeks to go, the goal was twofold: fill the room, and be able to measure exactly what the advertising was producing.

What We Did:

Built the measurement first. We installed the Meta pixel and Conversions API with server-side deduplication. Purchase, checkout, view-content and registration events were mapped. The pixel was deployed on thecoolchurch.com through Google Tag Manager. Website, livestream and Eventbrite checkout all fed one dataset. Purchase event match quality reached 8.3 of 10.

Launched four campaigns, not one.

Moved money to where it worked. Eventbrite’s own ad product was costing $3.52 a click. Meta was costing $0.38 for the same traffic. That budget moved.

Read the audience data and acted on it. Warm audiences were converting at a lower cost per ticket against a higher cost for cold broad, and cold lookalikes. Budget shifted toward the people who already knew the church, while prospecting kept running to prove reach beyond the congregation.

Key Results

575 tickets into a 578-seat room. The paid tickets alone cleared the 500 goal.

Our Meta campaigns were credited with a 6.02x return on ad spend, working alongside the church’s email list, pulpit announcements, and congregation to fill the room.

Campaign Purchases* Cost per purchase ROAS
Prospecting 64 $15.65 5.33x
Retargeting 54 $12.89 5.48x
Abandoned checkout 35 $18.75 7.01x
Pastors / group sales 34 $14.05 9.96x

*Meta purchases are orders, and one order can include more than one ticket. Attribution window: 7-day click, 1-day view.

The smallest campaign was the best one.

Our most targeted campaign, aimed at pastors buying seats for their women’s teams, delivered a 9.96x return. That was roughly double anything else running.

It worked because it spoke to one specific person: a direct video invitation from the church’s own leadership to other pastors.

Narrow beat broad.

She's COOL sign at a COOL Church women's conference outdoor gathering

 

Want to know what your advertising is actually producing?

We start by making it measurable. Then we make it work.

Book a call
Back to Case Studies

Now Accepting New Clients. Complete this form to book a free consultation.

Give Back

We strongly believe in giving our time, talents and treasures to help the human race live, learn and love better. We’re not doing this to look cool, we’re doing this because it’s the right thing to do. It’s for the greater good.

– Andre Kay- CEO & Founder of Sociallybuzz

01% Pledge

Sociallybuzz is integrating Philanthropy into our Business! Read More